Checking CSRF implementation in 182 calculator files... ❌ ac-btu-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ age-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ❌ age-difference-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ age-in-days-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ baby-cost-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ bmi-calculator-saudi.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ bmi-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ❌ body-fat-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ body-fat-percentage-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ book-reading-time-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ break-even-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ business-startup-cost-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ business-valuation-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ caffeine-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ calculators.php - No forms (display only) ✅ calorie-calculator-enhanced.php - Has CSRF protection ⚠️ calorie-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ✅ car-insurance-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ car-loan-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ car-payment-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ car-registration-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ carbon-footprint-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ career-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ career-path-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ cloud-storage-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ compound-interest-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ concrete-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ credit-card-payoff-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ currency-converter-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ data-usage-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ date-calculator-days-between.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ debt-payoff-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ debt-to-income-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ discount-calculator-shopping.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ discount-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ✅ domestic-helper-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ driving-school-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ due-date-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ electricity-bill-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ emergency-fund-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ end-of-service-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ expat-levy-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ fidya-kaffarah-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ freelance-income-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ freelance-rate-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ fuel-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ fuel-cost-calculator-trip.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ gas-mileage-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ gold-price-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ gpa-calculator-university.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ gpa-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ grade-average-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ grade-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ grade-percentage-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ grade-weighted-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ hajj-cost-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ℹ️ hajj-cost-calculator_ENHANCED.php - No forms (display only) ❌ heart-rate-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ heart-rate-zones-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ hemophilia-treatment-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ hijri-birthday-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ home-renovation-cost-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ housing-rent-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ hydration-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ ideal-weight-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ income-tax-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ international-visa-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ internet-bill-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ internet-speed-requirement-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ investment-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ iqama-renewal-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ islamic-finance-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ islamic-inheritance-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ islamic-loan-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ life-insurance-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ loan-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ❌ loan-emi-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ macro-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ macros-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ meal-prep-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ medical-insurance-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ mobile-bill-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ mortgage-calculator-saudi.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ mortgage-early-payoff-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ moving-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ moving-cost-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ muqeem-fees-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ murabaha-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ nafaqah-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ nitaqat-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ overtime-pay-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ ovulation-calculator-server.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ ovulation-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ pace-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ paint-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ parking-cost-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ passport-renewal-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ⚠️ paycheck-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ❌ percentage-calculator-advanced.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ percentage-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ✅ pregnancy-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ pregnancy-due-date-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ profit-margin-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ property-tax-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ protein-calculator-from-server.php - No forms (display only) ℹ️ protein-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ protein-intake-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ qiwa-fees-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ qurbani-cost-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ reading-speed-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ reading-time-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ real-estate-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ rent-vs-buy-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ rental-yield-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ retirement-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ retirement-savings-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ roi-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ running-pace-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ sadaqah-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ sadaqah-jariyah-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ sadaqah-monthly-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ salary-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ salary-increase-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ salary-tax-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ saudi-electricity-bill-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ saudi-water-bill-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ⚠️ savings-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ✅ scholarship-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ school-fees-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ screen-time-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ shipping-cost-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ silver-price-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ simple-interest-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ sitemap-calculators.php - No forms (display only) ❌ sleep-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ sleep-cycle-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ solar-panel-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ steps-to-distance-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ stock-profit-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ student-loan-payoff-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ study-hours-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ study-time-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ tdee-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ tile-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ❌ time-duration-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ❌ tip-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ℹ️ trip-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ trip-cost-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ tuition-savings-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ tv-screen-size-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ tv-size-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ umrah-cost-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ⚠️ vat-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ✅ visa-cost-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ vitamin-d-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ℹ️ wallpaper-calculator.php - No forms (display only) ✅ water-bill-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ❌ water-intake-calculator.php - Has form but NO CSRF protection ✅ wedding-budget-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ weighted-percentage-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ✅ work-hours-calculator.php - Has CSRF protection ⚠️ zakat-calculator.php - Has token generation but missing validation ⚠️ zakat-calculator_ENHANCED.php - Has token generation but missing validation ============================================================ SUMMARY: Files checked: 163 Files with forms: 134 ✅ Protected with CSRF: 59 ❌ Missing CSRF protection: 75 FILES NEEDING CSRF PROTECTION: ============================================================ - ac-btu-calculator.php - age-calculator.php - age-difference-calculator.php - bmi-calculator-saudi.php - bmi-calculator.php - body-fat-calculator.php - book-reading-time-calculator.php - business-startup-cost-calculator.php - business-valuation-calculator.php - calorie-calculator.php - car-payment-calculator.php - carbon-footprint-calculator.php - career-calculator.php - cloud-storage-calculator.php - compound-interest-calculator.php - credit-card-payoff-calculator.php - data-usage-calculator.php - date-calculator-days-between.php - discount-calculator-shopping.php - discount-calculator.php - due-date-calculator.php - freelance-rate-calculator.php - fuel-cost-calculator-trip.php - gpa-calculator-university.php - grade-calculator.php - grade-percentage-calculator.php - grade-weighted-calculator.php - hajj-cost-calculator.php - heart-rate-calculator.php - hijri-birthday-calculator.php - home-renovation-cost-calculator.php - hydration-calculator.php - ideal-weight-calculator.php - income-tax-calculator.php - internet-speed-requirement-calculator.php - life-insurance-calculator.php - loan-calculator.php - loan-emi-calculator.php - meal-prep-calculator.php - medical-insurance-calculator.php - mortgage-calculator-saudi.php - moving-calculator.php - overtime-pay-calculator.php - ovulation-calculator-server.php - pace-calculator.php - parking-cost-calculator.php - paycheck-calculator.php - percentage-calculator-advanced.php - percentage-calculator.php - reading-speed-calculator.php - rent-vs-buy-calculator.php - retirement-savings-calculator.php - running-pace-calculator.php - sadaqah-monthly-calculator.php - salary-increase-calculator.php - saudi-electricity-bill-calculator.php - saudi-water-bill-calculator.php - savings-calculator.php - screen-time-calculator.php - shipping-cost-calculator.php - silver-price-calculator.php - simple-interest-calculator.php - sleep-calculator.php - solar-panel-calculator.php - steps-to-distance-calculator.php - student-loan-payoff-calculator.php - study-time-calculator.php - tdee-calculator.php - time-duration-calculator.php - tip-calculator.php - tuition-savings-calculator.php - vat-calculator.php - water-intake-calculator.php - zakat-calculator.php - zakat-calculator_ENHANCED.php